This is how the turkey dinner went. I cooked it in a bag, I found a new kind that open at the top, which simplified my preparations. I prepped it last night which made today much easier.
I washed and cut up one large orange (peels included) and stuffed it into the bird cavity, along with an herb packet. I used sage, garlic and onion, which I tied into an unbleached coffee filter to make the packet (I always have coffee filters around so I don’t have to worry about keeping cheesecloth on hand). I softened 2 tablespoons of butter and mixed it with 1 heaping tablespoon of frozen orange juice concentrate, which made a thin paste that I spread over the entire bird (you’ll probably want to use a brush, I used my hands). All this took about 10 minutes. I refrigerated the bird until this morning when all I had to do was pop it into the oven.
I served it with roasted fingerling potatoes and salad. Asparagus is in season and I think it would make a great accompaniment as well. Whole cranberries were nice with the orange flavors.
The bird browned nicely in the bag, I’m sure due to the high sugar content of the butter/orange mixture. The flavor was subtle and complimented the turkey nicely. If I was going to do anything differently I would add a bit of sage to the butter mixture – it’s a good flavor with the orange. I was a bit unsure so I used it sparingly, I could have been a bit more daring.
Instead of gravy, I reduced the drippings for more of a glaze to use at the table. That was definitely the best use of it, adding a citrus tang to the final product. All and all a good turkey.
A couple of things. When I’ve done this before I’ve used Clementines – a complete accident really because they are sold in bulk and the last ones are usually overripe before they can be eaten. The flavor with Clemantines was much more intense, probably because the oranges were so overripe. Also, I prefer fresh turkeys, but this time of year they are hard to come by on a budget. I try and find un-basted frozen hens as a ‘next-best’ alternative. This time I couldn’t even find that and had to settle for a large tom. Turkeys over 16lbs can be difficult to cook and keep moist, but this one was surprisingly moist and tender.
Turkey isn’t just for Thanksgiving. Total prep time, including sides: 30 minutes. Cooking time: 2.5 hours (of which I only spent about 15 of those in the kitchen) – a smaller turkey would take about 1.5 to 2 hours, making it a great weekend meal.